Mayo historic designation appeal

Opposed the appeal, calling the 1942 building a testament to La Crosse's nursing history and arguing designation adds weeks, not years, to projects.

Mayo physician urged support for the appeal, saying healthcare changes fast and facilities must adapt; noted millions invested locally.

President of the Preservation Alliance of La Crosse countered Mayo's fears, citing the historic building code's flexibility, available matching materials, and research showing preservation stabilizes property values.

HPC member and former council candidate argued the building is a 'slam dunk' for designation and an important piece of women's history as a nurses' training school.

Mayo's regional facilities chair supported the appeal, invoking Mayo's founding value that 'the needs of the patient come first' and unknown future healthcare technology needs.

Mayo's community engagement director emphasized Mayo's preservation of historic records and stained glass inside the building, its millions in investment, and its partnership history with the city.

A historic preservation professional with 35 years in La Crosse opposed the appeal, citing past appeals that left surface parking lots where historic buildings once stood.